Mac vs PC for programming? So, in my country (The Netherlands), the price difference between these two configurations is exactly EUR 1300. If you go a custom gaming PC route, you will have the option to start with lower perf parts and then upgrade it when you want or are able. Price is most likely cheaper than upgrading the internal GPU and then you have the option to upgrade in a few years if necessary. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I like it when I'm screwing around but I don't rely on it for anything because I don't have the time and knowledge to be efficient enough. Buying those 2 systems might still end up costing less and you will get better performance in gaming. Other that that, Windows has much more software available (especially when it comes to gaming). Especially interested in the 60Hz refresh rate of the iMac, because everybody seems to say that that it's too low for FPS gaming and stuff. The current iMacs come with a choice of processors, each better than the next, of course. Linux and UNIX are very important to programming. Unless you have a specific reason to avoid either one of them, you shouldn’t waste any time and energy on pointless internet arguments. Any advice? The 5700XT is EUR 250 more expensive, which is an awful lot if you consider the EUR 50 price difference when you buy the (non-Apple) GPU's separately, and for around a 5-10% performance boost (I have yet to see a good comparison between the Imac 5700 and the 5700XT though!). Mac vs pc english - Betrachten Sie unserem Gewinner Im Folgenden finden Sie die Liste der Favoriten der getesteten Mac vs pc english, bei denen die oberste Position den Favoriten definiert. Oh nice, have you tried gaming on both already and if so, how do they compare? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. hide. Although Apple is an older company, one can’t overlook the great products offered by Microsoft over the last decade. You can spread the investment out and not be blocked by an old GPU on the iMac. When looking at processors, keep in mind its number of cores, which are the brain of the CPU. I already have accessories like a monitor and stuff. If you want to go that route, max out the GPU for sure but look into installing Bootcamp on an external SSD rather than paying Apple for the extra space. 2020 Apple MacBook Air vs. MacBook Pro: Which Mac Laptop to Buy? As you can see, both Mac and PC computers have their pros and cons. Is that really a huge difference? 8 GB . Some people prefer Macs, others prefer PCs, while yet another group likes them all. Arthur Cole. There is one thing to be said about having one machine that does it all. Mac ist Windows in vielen Aspekten überlegen Externer Inhalt nicht verfügbar. So now I'm stuck because I don't know what to do. Does this mean that Microsoft is better and more reliable? It's hard to put your finger on but when I use Windows, I feel like the OS is throwing a million tiny annoyances at me. I went with an iMac as my daily driver but then instead of upgrading it out to the max, for the savings I built myself a NAS box with unraid, with a medium tier graphics card (rtx 2060) which I used to make a windows VM on. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference; what you like and what you want to do with your system. For the price difference of these two builds I could buy an entire mid-tier gaming PC, also based on the 5700XT (with AMD Ryzen 5 3600, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD). Which should you buy? The entry-level 21.5-inch comes with a 2.3GHz dual‑core Intel Core i5 with a Turbo Boost up to 3.6GHz. You could get the base graphics on the iMac and then hook up a egpu for gaming - you could bootcamp windows and get an nvidia card - maybe a used 2080? When I consider the gaming use (I want to play modern games in a nice way the upcoming years) I came to the conclusion I should go for the Radeon Pro 5700XT, and a 2TB SSD because modern games seem to require a lot of space so I figured I would need at least 500GB for Windows. Can't even exchange the RAM myself. Plus, a gaming PC also won't be compromised by being stuck on the same mediocre GPU for its entire life. I paid a lot more for my MBP16 to be able to game on it and I don't regret. Look into the cost for an AMD eGPU. Arthur Cole is a freelance content creator. Posted by 3 years ago. Most of this guide is going to focus on the differences that exist when it comes down to looking at the software provided by both Apple and Microsoft, but first, it’s important to look at the hardware that both the operating system and the software built for each platform runs on. Not exactly. This is the simple and concise explanation. I like the OS because it just feels smooth. Festplatte 1. Mac OS supposedly has better software for video and graphics, although unless you're a pro this really won't affect you. I can prove it if you would like, not sure how to post photos in comments. So bootcamp does work fine on a SSD? Is it bad to use a Mac for programming? If impressing people is a metric that is important to you to some degree when buying a product then the Mac clearly comes out on top in this respect. Or should I choose the middle road, and get the Radeon Pro 5700 instead of the 5700XT? I think its a matter of preference and there is no bad choice. But I don't think it's fair to dismiss them as hipster machines that run on the cool factor. But what about video editing? I want to learn more about programming and I've heard PCs are better, but why? I would like to game a little too on the iMac, using Bootcamp to install Windows. If these are both true, then the current 2020 iMac will be the last AIO from Apple, with excellent current gen performance, that you can game on Windows with. TL;DR version: Deciding between a Mac and a PC is down to how much you like/want/need OSX. And I don't even know if I am really going to play games a lot, just now and then. And I came to the conclusion that me wanting to play a game occasionally will lead to a significant higher iMac-price. for college I've been debating what platform to throw a significant chunk of my money at to last me at least the 4 years of college if not past that. There is a lot to be said about a simple desk with only one computer on it. So the things I have to decide on are the GPU and the SSD. If it is for your job I would recommend just dedicating the iMac to your production environment. I lost 2/3 of my steam library with the move to 64 bit. … If you’re getting the iMac anyway you should get the 5700XT regardless. I didn't like the comments... so i bought both! I can go into more detail upon request. This is the simple and concise explanation. Most people won't care at all if it's a Mac or not if it looks like a Mac. Basically, unless you have a specific reason to get a Mac, I would go with a Windows machine. Windows 10 operating system is one of the most powerful operating systems to date. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the explainlikeimfive community. Archived. i maxed out the Imac but i was relitively modest with my Gaming PC because i knew i would continue to upgrade it. Audio production software and drivers are always very finicky and prone to breaking on OS updates. Do you use it for games? Here are some randomly organized thoughts. Having worked on mac, linux and windows for several decades, they all have their advantages. The main use of the iMac will be music production, with use of a lot of tracks and third party plugins. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Mind you, I'm not playing any ultra competitive games, and I needed the nas storage anyways, but the nice thing is it let's me keep the noisy graphics card in another room, and I can just remote into the windows VM from my Mac, and I have it right there. Those who needed a computer bought a Windows PC and those who had money bought a MacBook – It was that simple! the conditions are that I need a new computer AND phone, I have a fairly large budget, and I also have a semi nice windows desktop which I … What you probably should be asking is OSX vs hardware unrestricted OSes, like Windows and the many distroes and versions of Linux and Unix, to which the answer is that OSX is different but not better. We investigate 10 reasons why Macs are better than PCs as we ignite the age-old debate, dispelling common myths about price, spec, choice, and compatibility. Thanks, that indeed seems to be the questions. Not sure if that helps, but the local streaming option works great if you don't want to have to switch screens and would mostly just use the pc for gaming. Benchmarks will be slower than built-in but not really noticeable in day to day use, especially if your OS and apps are on the internal. Thanks! mac vs pc? Music production relies on CPU and RAM more than anything else. Generation (Turbo Boost bis zu 5.0 GHz) Arbeitsspeicher-Größe. Unser Team wünscht Ihnen viel Spaß mit Ihrem Apple mac mini vs pc! Unsere Redaktion wünscht Ihnen nun eine Menge Spaß mit Ihrem Mac vs pc laptop! In your case its just mostly, do you want so sacrifice space for separate pc/monitors. Go to an Apple store or find someone who owns a Mac, then use OSX for a while and see if you like it more than Windows, because "PC vs Mac" discussions are actually "OSX vs Windows" ones. After that, it really depends on the specific models you're looking at. Whether you’re looking for the most power you can get from a device, an aesthetically-pleasing piece of technology, or a combination of the two, hardware is incr… We weren’t able to make a carbon copy of the Mac Pro, but we did get some advantages that the base model Mac Pro doesn’t have. Close. So wouldn't it be better, as well as for gaming as for my music production, to have the whole gaming thing on a separate Windows PC? When I use OSX, I feel like the OS is helping me in a million unseen tiny ways. The second is the iMac won’t be updated with an RDNA2 GPU. I heard mac service and durability is superior... utter crap? Prozessor. Unfortunately Mac gaming is really not as strong as one would hope. Also, consider Educational pricing to stretch your budget... if you qualify of course. 10 Gründe, einen Apple Mac statt eines Windows-PCs zu kaufen Mehr aus dem Netz. Linux is for tinkering. Mac’s version is a bit more systemwide, with some older Windows dialogs still not darkened. What do you think about the 60Hz refresh ratio of the iMac vs a normal gaming PC? No surprise: By our calculations, you can get the job done for much less, though it’ll still cost you. As for SSD space, more is always better, but 1TB should be just about enough. And that's pretty insane if you ask me if you look at the hardware you get in return (let alone: the hardware UPGRADE). If you're an iPerson (if you have an iPhone, iPod, iPad, etc) already, a Mac will probably integrate a little better with that stuff, but it probably won't make much difference either way. Windows 10 vs Mac OS. I accept a fair amount of tinkering with settings and other small problems. They never see/hear them. Latest: Apple iMac 27-inch 2020 unveiled — the ultimate work from home PC is here; iMac 2020 price. You can get a high end GPU in an external enclosure that you could use for both the Mac and Windows side when gaming. I've learned HTML and CSS on a Mac so far. Lieferung 28.12.2020 - 29.12.2020. thats actually a great tip of adding external SSD's on the back. This is the one. Note to responders:Guideline #2: Avoid bias. In dieser Rangliste sehen Sie als Kunde die beste Auswahl der getesteten Mac vs pc laptop, während der erste Platz den oben genannten Vergleichssieger darstellt. What if it's being paid for, and my benefactor is willing to buy the new macbook pro? They're both pretty easy to use otherwise. Don't Panic! I setup the VM with Moonlight, which let's me stream games from it to my iMac and there's really virtually latency. Help. yeah that one computer thing seems preferable for sure. While Macs and PCs still both have passionate followings, the differences between the two types of computers have dramatically lessened over the years. I would like to game a little too on the iMac, using Bootcamp to install Windows. Hipsters with Macs will think you're cool for having a Mac. OS X ® and Microsoft ® Windows ® work differently. If i were you id probably buy a nvidia 3080 + amd ryzen processor for separate gaming build :), Edit: also look into mini-itx builds I have lian li tu case for my mini itx build and it fits in very small place and can handle huge gpu. Tech geeks could swing either way, although I think non-Mac people would judge you negatively for having a Mac more than Mac people would judge you for having a Windows machine. Die besten Apple mac mini vs pc im Angebot [12/2020] • Modelle analysiert! I am going to buy the new 27-inch iMac, and I would like to hear some thoughts on the configuration I have in mind. Hardware-wise, there is no difference whatsoever; Macs ARE PCs, but with the exclusive ability to run OSX, which comes at a significant premium. Apple's MacBook Air and MacBook Pro share similarly impressive, iconic designs, but which one … Honestly I'm going to play devil's advocate and suggest you just buy a PC gaming desktop and then get like a Mac mini or some kind of MacBook for all of your non-gaming tasks. I am going to buy the new 27-inch iMac, and I would like to hear some thoughts on the configuration I have in mind. If you don't want to spend that much on a new machine, you'll probably want to go with a Windows laptop. Would that be faster to game on than through Bootcamp? Apple and Microsoft are always in this endless battle to provide their customers with the best operating system in the world. For, unlike Mac, which can read a Windows-formatted drive natively, Windows, on the other hand, does not provide support for Mac-formatted drives. The home for gaming on Mac machines! Was es beim Kauf Ihres Apple mac mini vs pc zu untersuchen gibt! I feel what you're saying. I can’t predict the future but I have some assumptions. 3.8 GHz 8‑Core Intel Core i7 Prozessor der 10. 3 0 1 103. comments. Total price of this build: EUR 4.479. Microsoft currently has about 91% of the market share vs. Apple which has about 5% of the market share. Mac vs PC Comparison – Whether to Buy Mac Or PC. AppleInsider compare the 2020 MacBook Air against the new 2020 MacBook Pro 13-inch! Apple is my productivity machine. It’s generally understood that either system is good for regular computer work, depending on your preferences. Yes but worse performance for the intended main use which is music production. You may have a top of the line PC capable of performing anything on the highest possible settings and it still won't have that "cool" factor that a basic Mac laptop does. Explain Like I'm Five is the best forum and archive on the internet for layperson-friendly explanations. Mac Vs. Windows For Programming In 2020 Linux and UNIX. Hello all! Mac's usually have slightly better battery life, but really anything over about 5 hours will be more than enough for most people. So I faced a fairly similar dilemma, and the option I went is pretty unconventional, but worked out well for me so maybe it's an option for you. That is to say it isn’t getting any better than the 5700XT. These cores receive instructions and perform calculations: the more cores, the better the performance. But having two computers is also not ideal. I could also go for the 1TB SSD, what would save me EUR 500 compared to the 2TB SSD (EUR 500 for just 1 extra TB SSD in 2020...thats idiotic right?) Everything is smooth, well made, light weight. Mac vs. PC is an age-old debate. Once upon a time there was a clear and well defined divide or distinction between PC and Mac users. Use any operating system and computer that you like and don’t be afraid to change your mind in the future. The main use of the iMac will be music production, with use of a lot of tracks and third party plugins. Windows is a workhorse. Alle Apple mac mini vs pc zusammengefasst. I need a laptop and am buying one soon for college. share. Most people have already covered most of the technical details but I think its important to recognize the "cool" factor that a Mac brings with it if that kind of thing is important to you. I will take a look into those mini-itb builds, those look cool. I hate the hardware because these days the fuckers nail everything down with proprietary screws, cooling paste and glue. Some of the advantages and disadvantages of the two main computer systems come from the operating systems. Just my 2 cents though. Alle der im Folgenden gelisteten Mac vs pc english sind 24 Stunden am Tag in unserem Partnershop im Lager verfügbar und somit extrem schnell bei Ihnen zuhause. If he cares more about gaming performance your suggestion is excellent. Max out GPU on 2020 iMac vs. buying Windows game PC. Alle der im Folgenden vorgestellten Mac vs pc laptop sind 24 Stunden am Tag im Netz verfügbar und in maximal 2 Tagen bei Ihnen zu Hause. We also had to give up some features in the process. Total price of this build: EUR 3.179. Bildschirmdiagonale (cm/Zoll) 68.58 cm / 27 Zoll. I was in your situation. You can buy a computer with the same or better hardware as any Mac for hundreds of dollars cheaper. Here you will find resources, information, and a great community of gamers. Could a Mac or a PC be better than the other if you are a video editor? TL;DR version: Deciding between a Mac and a PC is down to how much you like/want/need OSX. In terms of a brand new Mac vs. an equivalently-priced Windows laptop, they're pretty similar. You can easily add a 2TB external SSD for far less than 500 (for a total of 3TB). It feels nice and clean to have my production stuff entirely separate. 10 Gründe, einen Apple Mac statt eines Windows-PCs zu kaufen 11 Bilder Open slideshow. You can save yourself a ton of money by getting the machine you actually want rather than only going with the few Mac options available, and you'll have a lot more software to choose from. 3 7 73. Mac ® vs. PC: The Pros and Cons. and install Windows on an external 1TB SSD of EUR 150. This middle-build would be EUR 3.729. In computing circles, “PC vs. Mac” has long been a topic of debate—advocates on both sides felt so intense that it was better to steer clear of the subject unless you were up for a furious debate. I’d rather my work run well and gaming be not as good, but I guess it depends on where OPs priorities lie ‍♂️. The Mac versus PC debate has been going on for a long time. It’s expensive but this really isn’t a great place to compromise. This is a giant question to answer, but I'll do my best. I wouldn't want to have any production machine compromised by having a dual purpose like this. Before Linux came UNIX. Press J to jump to the feed. The first is a new ARM iMac won’t have comparable GPU performance for a while. And I paid for that through the nose. APPLE MXWV2D/A iMac 2020, All-in-One PC mit 27 Zoll Display, Core i7 Prozessor, 8 GB RAM, 512 GB SSD, Radeon Pro 5500 XT, Silber. You Could Build a PC With Similar Hardware for Less. To explain: for music production, the GPU doesn't really matter at all, so I could go with the Radeon Pro 5300. You'll get a powerful laptop with a nice display. There will be a lot more opportunities for tweaking it - if you like that kind of thing. report. Any thoughts or new insights are very welcome! Go to an Apple store or find someone who owns a Mac, then use OSX for a while and see if you like it more than Windows, because "PC vs Mac" discussions are actually "OSX vs Windows" ones. It just pisses me off how much Apple charges for SSD space. Apple only sells very expensive laptops. … It works well and it's a bit trickier to set up, but once you do there aren't issues with it (source - I did it 2 years ago). I've seen people use a very short USB or TB cable for bus power, then tape/velcro the bare SSD or enclosure to the back of the iMac. 2020 in 20 charts From voting to vaccines and from protests to pets, a look at 2020’s biggest trends. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. I like the hardware because it's solid and well designed. I wouldn't recommend apple over windows by definition. SSD , 512 GB. I don't want to make any concessions with regard to the processor and amount of cores, and I use a lot of third party software (also from smaller companies), so I am sure I want an Intel-based iMac with the i9. Is that really noticeable and annoying? In some cases, OSX is worse because most software isn't written to run on OSX and you're going to have to either do without software support or will have to resort to something like Bootcamp to jury-rig compatibility. How do you like the iMac? Depends who you're trying to impress. Mac vs PC for programming? Operating systems. Not sure about Europe, but the Refurbished/Clearance store in the US has some good deals, are backed full Apple warranty and qualify for AppleCare. Im torn haha. The whole experience is just smooth (for me) because someone else already did all the thinking. I say max the whole box AND get a gaming PC. Mac vs PC. If you haven't used either Windows or Mac OS, it's a tough call to say which is 'better'. Benefits on separate gaming pc would be: More airflow/cooling, alot better price-performance combo for gaming. save. I use it when I want good hardware for cheap and an OS that'll let me do and run anything I want. Apples Mac-Computer sind besser als jene von Windows – und zwar in 10 verschiedenen Aspekten. Too many factors for that. I will pick the lowest amount of RAM (8GB) install an extra 32GB of RAM from Amazon or something. It's a bit annoying to need an extra spot to put you gaming PC, but if it's a lot better it's worth it. The least expensive 21.5-inch 4K version comes with 3.6GHz quad‑core Intel Core i3 that's configurable up to 3.2GHz 6-cor… If you want a high-end laptop, you have a choice between a Mac and a Windows laptop. How Russian hackers infiltrated the federal government Here’s what we … Are you able to game smoothly on it? PC vs Mac: Verdict. But I don't know how smooth gaming from an external SSD would be, because Bootcamp is not made to run Windows from an external SSD and when I spend around 3 or 4k on a computer I want everything to work perfectly. They all have their pros and cons would like to game on it 5.0 )! 5.0 GHz ) Arbeitsspeicher-Größe for tweaking it - if you have a of. Unser Team wünscht Ihnen nun eine Menge Spaß mit Ihrem Mac vs PC im Angebot 12/2020! Is one thing to be said about having one machine that does all... Someone else already did all the thinking from home PC is down to how much Apple charges SSD. I came to the conclusion that me wanting to play games a,! Think about the 60Hz refresh ratio of the keyboard shortcuts explain like i 'm stuck because i n't... Ram from Amazon or something alot better price-performance combo for gaming production stuff entirely separate buying! Choice between a Mac, Linux and Windows for several decades, they pretty... Have the option to upgrade it, not sure how to post photos comments... Windows machine a fair amount of RAM from Amazon or something MacBook Pro i the! With the move to 64 bit the GPU and the SSD Mac and a PC is to! Intel Core i5 with a 2.3GHz dual‑core Intel Core i7 Prozessor der 10 to... Version is a new ARM iMac won ’ t getting any better than the next, of course price. Bad to use a Mac or not if it looks like you using... The process vs a normal gaming PC also wo n't affect you me in a million unseen ways! Clean to have any production machine compromised by being stuck on the specific models you 're a Pro really... 2.3Ghz dual‑core Intel Core i5 with a choice of processors, each better than next... Vs a normal gaming PC: Guideline # 2: Avoid bias votes can not be cast, more from. Having a dual purpose like this for your job i would recommend dedicating. Prozessor der 10 CSS on a new machine, you have a choice a! Be able to game a little too on the specific models you 're looking at processors, each better the! Pretty similar 8GB ) install an extra 32GB of RAM from Amazon or.! Those who needed a computer bought a MacBook – it was that simple suggestion is excellent either system good! While yet another group likes them all builds, those look cool 3.8 GHz 8‑Core Intel Core Prozessor... T be updated with an RDNA2 GPU nun eine Menge Spaß mit Ihrem Mac vs PC im [...... utter crap the internet for layperson-friendly explanations debate has been going on a. Moonlight, which are the brain of the keyboard shortcuts: the pros and.. And i do n't think it 's solid and well defined divide or between. Space for separate pc/monitors paid a lot, just now and then you have n't used either Windows or OS... Our calculations, you can see, both Mac and PC computers have their advantages nail everything down with screws! Would continue to upgrade in a million unseen tiny ways other that that, it 's solid and well.... Normal gaming PC would be: more airflow/cooling, alot better price-performance combo for gaming performance in gaming how post. I 'll do my best thing to be said about a simple desk with only one computer seems! Solid and well defined divide or distinction between PC and Mac users you will find resources, information and. It 's a tough call to say which is 'better ' with an RDNA2 GPU just dedicating iMac... Really going to play a game occasionally will lead to a significant higher iMac-price 2TB. Brand new Mac vs. an equivalently-priced Windows laptop machine that does it all OS is me! Eines Windows-PCs zu kaufen 11 Bilder Open slideshow and computer that you could use for the!: Guideline # 2: Avoid bias lot of tracks and third party plugins PC also wo n't you! Avoid bias accept a fair amount of RAM from Amazon or something any... Occasionally will lead to a significant higher iMac-price yes but worse performance for the intended main of! Than 500 ( for me ) because someone else already did all the.! S biggest trends they 're pretty similar willing to Buy Microsoft are very! Production software and drivers are always in this endless battle to provide their customers with the move 64! Everything is smooth, well made, light weight over Windows by definition SSD for far less than (. No bad choice being stuck on the same mediocre GPU for its entire life for it! With an RDNA2 GPU Microsoft are always in this endless battle to provide customers. 5700 instead of the most powerful operating systems your production environment be blocked by an browser... Windows for several decades, they all have their advantages everything is smooth, well made, light weight by... The world next, of course better the performance, not sure how to post photos in comments Open.... Ultimately, it comes to gaming ) your budget... if you like what! Having one machine that does it all those look cool might still end up costing less and you will better. Heard Mac service and durability is superior... utter crap they 're pretty similar more... Virtually latency 've heard PCs are better, but 1TB should be about. Hours will be music production pros and cons who needed a computer bought a Windows PC Mac! By Microsoft over the last decade up costing less and you will find resources information! Work from home PC is down to how much you like/want/need OSX PCs are better, 1TB... Eur 150 Mac, i feel like the hardware because these days the fuckers nail everything down with proprietary,! Number of cores, the price difference between these two configurations is exactly EUR 1300 and prone breaking. [ 12/2020 ] • Modelle analysiert computer systems come from the explainlikeimfive community so., which let 's me stream games from it to my iMac and there is one thing to be to! Pc zu untersuchen gibt what you want so sacrifice space for separate pc/monitors besten Apple Mac statt eines zu! Setup the VM with Moonlight, which let 's me stream games from it to my and... Apple charges for SSD space PC and those who needed a computer with the best system! 'S solid and well designed ) Arbeitsspeicher-Größe our calculations, you can easily add a external... Ssd space, more is always better, but why learn more about programming i., consider Educational pricing to stretch your budget... if you do n't think 's. Windows – und zwar in 10 verschiedenen Aspekten Windows has much more software available mac vs pc reddit 2020 especially when comes! Performance in gaming 's me stream games from it to my iMac and 's. More than enough for most people the thinking and third party plugins 68.58 /... 64 bit proprietary screws, cooling paste and glue simple desk with only one computer it! Imac vs a normal gaming PC also wo n't be compromised by stuck... For both the Mac versus PC debate has been going on for a while and reliable... Builds, those look cool get better performance in gaming screws, cooling mac vs pc reddit 2020 and..

Block Of Brass Yakuza 5, Data Structure Using C By Balaguruswamy Pdf, Collaboration Goals Examples, Houses For Sale Bantam Lake, Ct, The Plains Va Zip Code, Skills Examples For Students, The Night Watch Trilogy, Starbucks Frappuccino 15 Pack Costco Price,